To paraphrase the late, great Rodney Dangerfield, independent insurance agents don't get no respect.

It's bad enough that a recent career survey ranked your profession below janitors, bookbinders and even editors (see my related blog, ”At least you're not a roustaboust“). Now, the latest Forrester Research consumer survey reveals that your customers don't even find you fun.

The survey, conducted over the Internet last October, gave independent agents an overall score of “okay” from 4,600 consumers who had interacted with a variety of companies. Forrester asked consumers to rate insurance companies on three areas: “meets needs,” “easy to work with” and “enjoyable.” Several insurers, including USAA, Liberty Mutual, Progressive and The Hartford, were ranked “good” by respondents. But when it came to being “enjoyable,” consumers rated independent agents “poor,” while giving them “good” ratings for “meets needs” and “easy to work with.”

What does this mean? Evidently it's not an ease-of-use issue; respondents ranked agents “good” on meeting customer needs and being easy to work with. And it's not just a carrier issue, either. Savvy carriers know, and slower carriers are discovering, that it's not enough to simply provide ease of use through technology and real-time services — in fact, that's just the starting point (see this related article on Deep Customer Connections' recent survey on agents telling carriers they need more ease of use).

From just looking at the numbers, the problem seems to be with the agency system itself, as several carriers got high marks from consumers as being enjoyable to work with. Granted, the results may be skewed because of the focus on personal lines insurance purchasers, but this dissing of insurance agents shouldn't be the case. It all boils down to the perception of insurance agent as unnecessary middleman, useful perhaps, but more likely just another roadblock between the customer and the underwriter.

The irony is, agents are in a much better position to deliver real customer satisfaction — and yes, even “fun” – than any insurer ever could. In our monthly agency success stories, we speak with agency owners, especially those in small towns or rural areas, who don't think twice about emergency customer visits, of knowing the names and ages of teenaged drivers about to be added to a family's auto policy, of engaging customers in intimate conversations to discover their plans for the future and how insurance coverage can help protect those plans. These agencies and their employees are also connecting to their communities through charitable work, recruitment at area schools, and other ways to create engagement with customers and prospects. It's a testament to the level of service that every independent agent should be providing to valued customers, especially at a time when every customer counts.

And inevitably in today's world, part of that customer outreach is through intelligently developed and executed social media planning. Maybe that's where the smart carriers have an edge on agencies — they have the financial wherewithal and staffing to plunge right in. (Luckily, you don't need these resources to make good use of this new tool: check out ACT's recommendations for creating a social media policy for your independent agency).

With more insurers, including traditional direct writers, using multiple distribution methods, the stakes are higher than ever for agents to prove themselves invaluable to their customers — not just by meeting their insurance needs in a smart and timely way, but by engaging with them on multiple levels.

What's your agency doing to build your brand perception with your customers?

Special Reports /

Toops Scoops: You're No Fun

Related Stories

Recommended For You