In spite of a new business environment, cultural inertia and other issues stall efficiency initiatives
By Michael Ha
Insurers’ chief information officers face continuing challenges from entrenched attitudes, a new regulatory environment and managements that have different vision for technology, technology analysts told a systems meeting here.
In the insurance industry, there have been a lot of companies that think “if it isn’t broken, let’s not worry about fixing it,” especially when it comes to replacing older legacy systems, said Kimberly Harris-Ferrante, vice president and research director at Gartner Inc. in Stamford, Conn.
Ms. Harris-Ferrante was one of a panel of technology analysts who spoke at last week’s Town Hall Meeting at the ACORD-LOMA Insurance Systems Forum.
The group advised that there is a new business landscape offering opportunities as well as problems for CIOs.
Continuing to articulate the challenges, Ms. Harris-Ferrante said, “We’ve heard many companies complain about the new [governance] regulations and regarding compliance reporting, and how they had to decrease their discretionary [technology] spending because some of the money they were going to spend on more core activities has been diverted into compliance initiatives.”
Additionally, when analysts ask CIOs where they are investing their tech budgets, “we are finding that CIO priorities are not in line with CEO objectives. CIOs tell us that their major issues are privacy, security breaches, regulatory compliance, and how to deal with business disruptions,” said Ms. Harris-Ferrante, while CEOs cite retaining customers and growing revenues. “That’s like number seven [for CIOs] compared to all the operational areas they are focusing on.”
The problem today, she said, is that “we can talk about great deeds, looking at new customers and growing market share, but the reality is we are spending more time on operations. That’s where our technology money is going.”
When it comes to the IT budget, the challenge is to realign the percentage of spending for maintenance with investments in transformation projects that can grow the business long term, noted Todd Eyler, vice president of financial strategies for Gartner Inc. “When you look at a typical IT budget, a big chunk is dedicated to just keeping the lights on,” he said.
Still, the smartest companies are those that look ahead and launch initiatives to improve their systems, according to the panelists, who said such forward-thinking efforts will pay dividends very soon.
“The smartest companies–those that will be leaders in five years–are really focused on aggressively consolidating the back office,” said Mr. Eyler. Indeed, the panelists warned that focusing on revenue growth without also paying attention to policy administration, claims and other support functions will prevent carriers from fulfilling their promises to new customers.
The panelists advised that CIOs must deal with a new regulatory environment, which offers opportunities to streamline business data management, but at the same time can drain resources that could go to broader and more strategic information technology projects.
“Now, for example, mutual insurers have to respond much more like publicly traded companies than in the past. Regulations are demanding it,” said Matthew Josefowicz, manager of the insurance practice at Celent Communications, headquartered in Boston. “If you can’t get a view into your financials across your organization easily at any given time during the day, you know you will have some problems,” he said.
Ms. Harris-Ferrante also noted that the reason insurers are still coping with inefficiencies, such as duplicate data entries, is that “application systems and developments of standards like those from ACORD have all been works-in-progress in the last few years.” However, she noted, the industry is just at the point where standards initiatives are coming together.
“This gives us an opportunity to put the systems together and have the data flow seamlessly through the organization, and to have it in a common, standardized format,” she said. “So, I think we are just now at the turning point where we can start tackling this head on.”
Cynthia Saccocia, research director for insurance at TowerGroup in Needham, Mass., observed that when she talks to insurer CIOs, she notices they are starting to incorporate more language similar to that heard in the manufacturing sector–such as comparing their processes to a conveyor belt–and as a result to embrace more efficient data-management systems.
“They are talking about moving data and information on the conveyor belt and moving away from double-data entry and away from separate silos,” she said.
Flag: “What They’re Saying”
“CIOs tell us that their major issues are privacy, security breaches, regulatory compliance, and how to deal with business disruptions.”
Kimberly Harris-Ferrante, VP, Gartner Inc.
“When you look at a typical IT budget, a big chunk is dedicated to just keeping the lights on.”
Todd Eyler, VP, Gartner Inc.
“If you can’t get a view into your financials across your organization easily at any given time during the day, you know you will have some problems.”
Matthew Josefowicz, manager, Celent Communications.