Study To Insurers: Rethink Your CAT Reserves

By Daniel Hays

NU Online News Service, Feb. 14, 2:59 p.m. EST?Based on a study of the 2004 hurricane year, a new scientific study suggests that insurers need to revise their thinking in setting claims reserves for natural catastrophes.[@@]

The research was done by Carvill, a Chicago-based intermediary for specialty reinsurance. It was prepared by Carvill's Chicago-based ReAdvisory group based on an examination of recent weather patterns and hurricane damage to the coastal United States, particularly in the State of Florida and also highlighted the unusual serial nature and varied windswaths of catastrophe events.

According to the research by ReAdvisory Vice President Steve Smith, who has a doctorate in atmospheric physics, a repeat of something like the 2004 Hurricane season could come within 50 to 70 years.

The report added that "Given that the activity rates for hurricanes in the Atlantic basin are in an enhanced phase (due to a number of climatic factors), the return period might be shorter, at least in the medium term (20 to 40 years).

It suggested that the reinsurance/insurance industry would react to this potential catastrophic repeat by improving its modeling, changing the current per-occurrence model of catastrophe coverage and reviewing levels of risk retention.

Mr. Smith said the reserving question was highlighted by the number of large companies whose recent fourth-quarter financial reports included millions of dollars in additional loss numbers for hurricane events that exceeded their first estimates.

"We're going to see more as the [financial] result season goes on," he said.

A risk retention review, the paper said, could lead to companies reducing the amount of risk they take on. The firm also expects the use of per-event deductibles by companies will decline--replaced by seasonal deductibles. In Florida, it was noted, insurers estimate this change will increase rates 3 percent.

The report said that the 2004 hurricane season was unusual in one crucial way--seriality.

Mr. Smith, found that, as of today, none of the currently available catastrophe models take into account the cumulative effect of serial storms: such as increased cost of raw materials, lack of availability of claim adjusters, and increased susceptibility due to damage from prior storms.

"Many insurers will have to critically re-evaluate their appetite for risk retention, improve their models, and review how deductibles should be handled moving forward, particularly if the market moves to a per-season deductible structure," Mr. Smith said.

"Based on published scientific studies, insurers and reinsurers can expect heightened levels of hurricanes to continue for another 10-40 years," he added. "I strongly believe that the modeling of hurricanes, especially those in clusters, will have to improve."

According to the ReAdvisory findings, until last year's hurricane season, the likelihood of a $20 billion loss was mainly measured as the likelihood of a single large event causing the damage. The 2004 hurricane season, the company said, has shown that the risk of losses accumulating from multiple storms must also be considered.

ReAdvisory said its findings are based upon known and measurable facts, but there are two "wild cards" that need further consideration and could bring the future into focus.

One area of concern that has not been factored in the predicted return cycle of the hurricane "cluster" year is global warming, ReAdvisory said.

"Weather patterns continue to change and we cannot yet determine how global warming will sway current hurricane forecasts," Dr. Smith said.

ReAdvisory noted the importance of being mindful of where the hurricanes land. Are there any physical or meteorological phenomena that affect hurricane paths?

The firm noted that if Hurricane Andrew hit Miami only 10 miles north, potential damage was estimated at three to four times what actually occurred. "If any of the four major storms of 2004 had hit a major city, the damage could have been astronomical. More work is needed in this area," Mr. Smith said.

The ?2004 Hurricane Season in Review' white paper will be available online at http://www.carvill.com.

Mr. Smith said among other issues the paper raises is the issue of how the industry is going to look at catastrophe models.

Some of the catastrophe modeling companies, he said, will make fundamental changes. "It's going to change the industry."

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free PropertyCasualty360 Digital Reader

Your access to unlimited PropertyCasualty360 content isn’t changing.
Once you are an ALM digital member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking insurance news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Weekly Insurance Speak podcast featuring exclusive interviews with industry leaders
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical converage of the employee benefits and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, BenefitsPRO and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.