PMA Withdraws Rating After Downgrade

Standard & Poor's has further downgraded its ratings on PMA Capital Corp., citing the insurers decreased financial flexibility, additional reserve concerns and uncertain strategic directions for its future. But PMA issued a statement protesting the rating agencys assessment and said it is immediately withdrawing from S&P rating process.

Its been a turbulent November for PMA Capital. The company had already suffered a round of ratings cuts from major ratings agencies after it surprised the marketplace with a $150 million pre-tax charge to boost reinsurance operation reserves.

The company then followed it up with a sudden management shakeup involving the departure of its chief executive John Smithson and chairman Frederick Anton. (See NU, Nov. 17, page 31)

In its latest ratings downgrade, S&P cut counterparty-credit and financial-strength ratings for PMA's reinsurance unit–called PMA Capital Insurance–to “double-B” from “triple-B” while lowering counterparty-credit and financial-strength ratings for PMA primary writers to “triple-B-minus” from “triple-B.” All ratings are on Credit Watch with “negative” implications.

These ratings actions reflect PMA Capitals “significantly diminished financial flexibility,” said S&P credit analyst Laline Carvalho. She also observed that since the reserve-boost announcement in early November, the companys stock has been trading “significantly below book value,” which hurts the insurers ability to raise funds in financial markets.

Currently, she said, S&P believes PMA Capital has enough liquidity at the holding company to service interest payments during “the next 12 months.”

Ms. Carvalho also worried that PMA Capitals “future strategic direction and organizational structure” remain unclear, citing the recent departure of the companys CEO and chairman, as well as the insurers decision to exit the reinsurance business.

Furthermore, reserve adequacy is still a concern. “PMA Capital remains exposed to further reserve development at its operating subsidiaries,” she said. “PMA Capital has recently announced that it has engaged an outside actuarial firm to review reserve adequacy at its primary writers in the fourth quarter of 2003.”

But PMA took a different view of its financial health, announcing that it disagrees with S&P findings. “While we appreciate any rating agency's obligation to express its opinion,” the company said, “we believe S&P's most recent action neglects to mention several facts that we believe are important.”

The company noted, for example, that reserves at its insurance operations–known as PMA Insurance Group companies–were unaffected by the $150 million charge and that, accordingly, the charge did not affect insurance operations statutory capital. The company also said the risk-based capital ratio at its insurance operations remains healthy. The company did not return calls seeking further comment.

S&P noted that at PMAs request, it will withdraw its ratings on operating units once the Credit Watch status has been resolved, which it expects will happen in the next two months. The rating agency said the resolution of the Credit Watch issue depends on completion of the insurers independent actuarial review on reserves. But S&P said it will continue to maintain ratings on PMAs outstanding debt.

Reproduced from National Underwriter Property & Casualty/Risk & Benefits Management Edition, November 26, 2003. Copyright 2003 by The National Underwriter Company in the serial publication. All rights reserved.Copyright in this article as an independent work may be held by the author.

Special Reports /

PMA Withdraws Rating After Downgrade

Related Stories

Recommended For You