|

Introduction

Commercial umbrella liability policies provide essential excess coverage for businesses, acting as a safety net above primary insurance policies such as general liability, auto liability, or employers’ liability. umbrella policies help protect against catastrophic losses, offering higher limits and broader coverage. However, like all insurance contracts, umbrella policies contain exclusions that limit their scope. One critical exclusion is the impaired property exclusion, which restricts coverage for certain types of property damage or loss of use claims. This article explores the impaired property exclusion in commercial umbrella liability policies, its purpose, variations in wording, scope, and real-world implications, providing examples to illustrate its application.

|

Understanding the Impaired Property Exclusion

The impaired property exclusion is a standard provision in both primary commercial general liability (CGL) policies and commercial umbrella policies. Its primary purpose is to exclude coverage for losses arising from defective products or work that do not involve physical damage to third-party property but result in economic losses, such as loss of use or diminished value. By excluding these claims, insurers limit their exposure to pure financial losses, which are typically covered under other types of insurance, such as professional liability or errors and omissions policies.

In commercial umbrella policies, the impaired property exclusion often mirrors the language found in the underlying CGL policy but may vary in scope depending on the insurer’s underwriting philosophy, the insured’s industry, or specific endorsements. The exclusion typically applies when:

1. The insured’s product or work is defective but does not cause physical injury to other property.
2. The loss of use involves tangible property that is not physically damaged.
3. The defect is correctable by repair, replacement, or adjustment of the insured’s product or work.

The exclusion ensures that the policy does not cover costs associated with fixing the insured’s defective work or product unless it causes direct physical damage to other property. For example, if a defective component in a machine causes the machine to malfunction without damaging it, the resulting downtime or loss of use may not be covered.

|

Purpose of the Impaired Property Exclusion

The impaired property exclusion serves several key purposes:

• Preventing Coverage for Economic Losses: It avoids covering purely financial losses, such as lost profits or downtime, which are not typically the domain of liability insurance.
• Encouraging Quality Control: By excluding coverage for defective work or products, the impaired property exclusion incentivizes businesses to maintain high standards in their operations.
• Aligning with Policy Intent: Liability policies cover bodily injury and property damage, not contractual disputes, or performance failures.
• Reducing Moral Hazard: The impaired property exclusion prevents insureds from relying on insurance to cover predictable business risks associated with poor workmanship or defective products.

Standard Wording of the Impaired Property Exclusion

The wording of the impaired property exclusion varies across policies, but a typical version in a commercial umbrella policy might resemble the language found in the Insurance Services Office (ISO) CGL form (CG 00 01). Below is an example of standard wording: