I read this morning an excerpt from Crispus Knight's book, "Three for Ship: A Swan Song to Dartmouth Beer Pong," a memoir of how Knight got into Dartmouth College and then promptly drank himself out of it. Washing out in this manner isn't unique to Knight; I saw people do it at my own alma mater, where a robust drinking culture fueled by an even more robust fraternity system (there were 16 national fraternities for a male student body of not even 1,000 students; 85% of whom went Greek). But in Knight's article, he notes how the heavy drinking culture and the rituals that go with it are so deeply ingrained into the fraternity system there, and how the fraternity system is so deeply ingrained into the Dartmouth experience, that a kid like him really had no chance at a place like Dartmouth. His chances of failure were 100%. He just didn't know it yet.

Now, Knight was, by his own admission, a broken individual primed to fail before he ever got to college. He takes full responsibility for his own downfall, and blames it not even a little bit on his school, which surely speaks well for his sense of personal accountability. Apparently, Knight's kryptonite was beer pong, and the particular variants at Dartmouth that fascinated him so much that he dedicated himself to them. He got so good at the game that he became a temporary school legend. He also became a drunk with no college education, at least for a while. (Knight ultimately did return to Dartmouth some years later, and he did earn a degree.)

I do not know of any colleges held responsible for their students' failure to negotiate the sometimes treacherous task of living away from home for the first time, dealing with unprecedented academic requirements, and figuring out how to integrate into the social scene without being swallowed whole by it. Personally, this is not an area where schools even should be held legally liable (though in today's environment, I suppose it's only a matter of time until they are, if they have not been already).