Judge: Bank of America CEO Moynihan Must Testify in MBIA Lawsuit

NEW YORK, April 12 - A New York judge has ruled that Bank of America CEO Brian Moynihan must testify in a lawsuit brought by bond insurer MBIA Inc. which claims the bank fraudulently induced it to insure risky mortgage-backed securities.

The judge said Moynihan could provide relevant testimony in the case due to his position as CEO, former president of investment banking and the fact that he oversaw the process of integrating Countrywide into Bank of America.

Bank of America acquired mortgage lender Countrywide in July 2008. MBIA filed a Countrywide later that year. In 2009, MBIA claimed Bank of America was liable for Countrywide's conduct.

Bank of America, the second-largest U.S. bank by assets, is fighting several legal cases following the global financial crisis and had sought to block MBIA efforts for Moynihan to give evidence.

MBIA was once the largest U.S. municipal bond insurer. It announced a restructuring in 2009 after incurring large losses insuring mortgage debt.

Bank of America had asked New York Supreme Court Justice Eileen Bransten to rule that Moynihan did not need to testify, arguing that MBIA was seeking his deposition only to harass the bank and that Moynihan had no unique knowledge about the case.

But the judge on Wednesday denied the request, according to court papers made public on Thursday.

"The knowledge Moynihan gained as part of the (Countrywide) Steering Committee is unique, and it is material and necessary to MBIA's successor liability claim," the judge said.

Moynihan was involved in "high-level decisions regarding the Countrywide transaction" and his testimony will not duplicate that of lower-level employees, she said.

MBIA declined to comment and Bank of America did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

The cases is MBIA Insurance Corp v. Countrywide Home Loans Inc et al, New York State Supreme Court, New York County, No. 602825/2008.

Comments

Resource Library

View All »

Learn and Apply the Secrets of Successful Businesses to Your...

What does it take to elevate your agency to be known as the best of...

Have you outgrown your QA system?

Your claims audit tools must handle organizational growth and changing best practices. Download the "25...

Complimentary Sales Closer Questionnaires for Commercial Residential Property Insurance

Help property owners or managers compare your commercial residential property insurance coverage vs. the competition....

The Latest Business Intelligence Capabilities to Reduce Costs and Enhance...

SIMS Insight is the advanced business intelligence module of SIMS Claims. Want more information? Download...

Top Trends in Roof Risk Mitigation

Get an in-depth look at the progression of the roof problem, including a four-step path...

When Banks Won't Help, Oak Street Funding Will.

Our commission-based loans are designed to help agents and brokers invest in their business, consolidate...

Home Run Leads are Here!

Our high quality leads will have you swinging for the fences and knocking your sales...

We Have Your New Formula for Success!

Your goal is to deliver maximum impact on those critical aspects of business that drive...

Complimentary White Paper: What Makes a House a Home?

The restoration vendor is the first person on site after a disaster strikes a home...

Complimentary Case Study on Data and Analytics Solutions

Infinilytics provided their client a solution platform with an increased scope of data insight and...

Producer Profiles: Share Your Stories

PropertyCasualty360 invites all brokers and agents to showcase their businesses and themselves with our readers. Tell us why you became an agent, what makes you successful and who you look up to--and we'll feature your achievements here on PC360 and highlight some of the profiles in the pages of Property Casualty 360 – National Underwriter and American Agent & Broker.

Agent & Broker Insider eNewsletter

Proven success tips and essential information to help agents and brokers grow their practice – FREE. Sign Up Now!

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.