Joplin Aftermath: A Reporter’s Notebook And Video Diary

To experience firsthand how the insurance industry is responding to the tornado that took out a large swath of Joplin, Mo. on May 22, I “embedded” on June 7 with State Farm Insurance, meeting with a local agent, two catastrophe claims representatives and an auto-lines specialist.

Subscribers to NU’s digital edition can click on the play button on the opposite page to watch a video report from the day in Joplin. If you’re reading this in print, don’t worry—you can check our website,, to see what we filmed.

Buddy System Averts “Meltdown”

“I’m sure I would have had a meltdown by now if I had not had the help of those State Farm partners,” Karen Rutledge tells me, describing the impact of State Farm’s “Buddy System,” where agents in unaffected areas offer their help to their colleagues in the center of the storm. “I could not have provided the service I wanted to provide if I hadn’t had that help,” says Rutledge—who has been an agent in Joplin for 25 years. “[These are] agents willing to walk away from their office and the way they make a living to come and help somebody else.”

The agents, many with claims experiences, were there to greet the “overwhelming” influx of policyholders. Not only were these buddies helping to write advance checks—they even set up a generator in Rutledge’s office so that when she arrived back from Chicago the morning after the tornado struck, “my team had power to operate the computers, take calls and help all the people coming in.”

Bathtub Refuge

Asked about some of the stories that most stuck out amidst all the turmoil and trauma, Rutledge says: “There’s just been so many people that were actually in their homes—nothing left—and I asked them where they were in the home, and over and over I have heard it was the bathtub. Word has gotten out over the years that the safest room in your house is possibly the bathroom. So many stories of people riding out the storm in their bathtub and that being all that was left, and not even in the same place in the house—maybe it was in the yard. It’s just amazing, seriously, that there were not more [fatalities].”

Seconding what Rutledge says about the tub, Steve Simpson, a catastrophe field claim representative  for State Farm, talked to a young married couple renting a house who got in the tub at the last second, pulled a mattress over themselves, “and they ended up two houses down, still in the bathtub. And the husband’s truck ended up where the bathtub used to be.”

Tech & The Tornado

Both Rutledge and the catastrophe claims reps I met with pointed out how much the technology they use has changed when responding to such events.

Claims reps now bring with them aerial photos of a policyholder’s property when they go to evaluate damage which they use to help make sure their measurements onsite are as accurate as possible.

And a device as ubiquitous as digital cameras has made a big difference, says Jasmine Coleman, another catastrophe field claim representative with whom I toured a totaled home. The digital approach gives them an opportunity to both see the photos immediately and take vastly more than they could in the (not-too-recent) days when they carried Polaroids.

“On my ride back from Chicago,” says Rutledge, “I actually was able from my BlackBerry to access the voicemails people had sent me and file the claims on my iPad through State Farm’s application. I was doing that in the car while my mother was frantically trying to get me back to where I needed to be. That same technology is available for the customers. I had numerous customers file their claim online, either through a computer or an application on their telephone. [Not too long ago,] we would have been trying to hand write this information and would have been only able to fax it.”

Lessons Learned

“Every person I’ve spoken with says their next house is going to have a basement and a safe room,” Simpson tells me. Indeed, the family who lived in the destroyed home we visited survived in their safe room—and left a poignant “We Lived” message on one of their remaining exterior walls, letting friends and neighbors know they had pulled through.

“I think now,” says Rutledge, “when we talk to people about the coverages on their homeowners—and we talk about here’s what we estimate with the tools we have on what it’s going to cost to rebuild—that we now have the experience to know the tools we work with are legitimate. And you need to seriously consider this even though you think, ‘Oh well, I could only sell it for this’—which has nothing to do with the cost of reconstruction. And I think people will realize that those [increased coverages] are worth considering.”

The other lesson both insureds and prospective policyholders are likely to take away? “That catastrophe does happen. And now we know because we’ve all experienced it, and it can be us, and it was us,” says Rutledge.

Personal Perspective

While I was mentally prepared for what I would experience in Joplin—and had probably seen hundreds of photos and nearly an hour of video clips—witnessing it in person was like a body blow to the senses. I found myself constantly whispering “Unbelievable”—because it was, simply, hard to accept as real carnage on such a mass scale.

The storm’s path was so wide—and its winds of such force—that there were neighborhoods where block after block after block was nothing but rubble. And I’ll never forget the trees—many still looking, but utterly denuded of all leaves, standing like stark skeletons on the desolate landscape.

As it happens, I went to a photography exhibition the Friday before I left for Joplin of images taken by the U.S. Army in Hiroshima in the weeks after the atomic bombing. And what I saw in Joplin was eerily, horrifyingly similar. 

Decompressing, Post-Disaster

The last two weeks have been highly emotional, stressful times for Simpson, Rutledge and Coleman. How do they plan to decompress when they are finally able to focus again on their personal lives?

“I have my State Farm trip to Disney scheduled for June 25 with all of my family and grandchildren, and I am definitely going,” says Rutledge. “We’ve had an EF-5 tornado, and I am going to Disney World.”

“What I do typically [when I return after a months-long assignment] is I walk into my house and literally just relax, complete release,” says Coleman. “I will take a good long nap that will probably be a day and a half.

Featured Video

Most Recent Videos

Video Library ››

Top Story

Identity theft takes the sparkle off of the holiday shopping season says new study

Cyber risks affect shopping patterns according to Generali Global Assistance.

Top Story

5 things to know about the NAIC's new cybersecurity model law

The NAIC's newly-adopted Insurance Data Security Model Law provides guidance for carriers, agents, brokers and their business partners.

More Resources


eNewsletter Sign Up

PropertyCasualty360 Daily eNews

Get P&C insurance news to stay ahead of the competition in one concise format - FREE. Sign Up Now!

Mobile Phone

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.