For decades, Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) plans were designed as a safety net, created as an option of last resort for homeowners unable to secure coverage in the private market. That role is rapidly changing.
Across the U.S., residual market mechanisms (state-run insurance programs like FAIR plans) now operate in more than 30 states. In catastrophe-prone regions like California, Florida and Colorado, FAIR plans are no longer a fallback but are becoming a primary source of property insurance. This is particularly pronounced as private carriers reduce exposure to wildfire, hurricane and other climate-related risks. Policy counts in FAIR plans have surged. For example, in California alone, exposure in these plans has climbed into the hundreds of billions.
The problem: The system wasn't built for this.
Systems built for the margins, now under pressure
FAIR plans were never designed to operate at scale. As insurers of last resort, their operations evolved to support relatively low policy volumes with lean teams and limited technology investment.
That legacy is now showing. Instead of modern, unified platforms, many FAIR plans rely on a patchwork of legacy systems, including separate tools for policy administration, billing, claims and reporting, layered over time to meet specific needs. They function individually but were never built to work together seamlessly.
Staff frequently rekey data across systems, reconcile discrepancies in spreadsheets, and manually compile reports to meet regulatory requirements. What began as temporary fixes have become standard processes, adding more hand-offs, more exceptions, and more opportunities for error.
This fragmentation creates friction at every stage of the policy life-cycle. Teams often work with inconsistent or incomplete data, slowing underwriting, servicing, and claims processing. It also adds to the burden of regulatory reporting, which is critical in residual markets. Missing fields, inconsistent coding, and manual corrections can delay filings and increase regulatory scrutiny.
To meet today's demand, FAIR plan leaders need to rethink their operational foundations. Integrated core systems, which bring policy, billing, and claims onto a single platform, offer a path forward. Instead of relying on manual fixes and disconnected tools, these systems create a unified environment where data flows seamlessly across the organization. Automated workflows that reduce rekeying allow staff to focus on underwriting and service rather than administrative work. A shared data model ensures all updates are reflected in real time, while built-in audit trails with standardized data improve reporting accuracy and simplify compliance.
Five principles for building what comes next
As FAIR plans evaluate their next steps, a few principles can make the difference between incremental improvement and meaningful change:
1. Enforce clean data at entry. Data quality problems in FAIR plans often surface first in state reporting, with missing fields or inconsistent coding requiring manual corrections before each submission. Systems should enforce clean data at entry to eliminate downstream fixes.
2. Prioritize simplicity and usability. Even as FAIR plans grow, they remain a secondary market for most agents. In many regions, an agent may only use a FAIR plan a few times a year. Systems should be intuitive and easy to navigate so infrequent users can operate them without retraining or support.
3. Choose a partner first. With limited in-house IT capacity, FAIR plans benefit from partners that bring both technical expertise and deep insurance knowledge. The right provider works side-by-side with the organization to solve problems, offering regular collaboration and direct access to solution builders.
4. Design for regulatory transparency. FAIR plans operate under intense regulatory oversight. Systems should make reporting easier, capture required data consistently, maintain clear audit trails, and enable faster, more reliable filings.
5. Build for volatility, not stability. Demand for FAIR plans is no longer predictable. Systems and processes should be able to flex with sudden shifts in policy volume, geographic concentration, and risk exposure without breaking under pressure.
FAIR plans are no longer operating at the margins of the insurance ecosystem. They must move beyond manual, fragmented operations to more connected, resilient platforms. Those that do will be better positioned to manage risk, maintain compliance, and deliver reliable service in an increasingly volatile environment.
Jaeton Cary is the Director of Sales at Finys, a provider of insurance software solutions for property and casualty insurers. With experience working closely with insurers and FAIR Plans, he focuses on helping organizations evaluate, implement, and modernize core systems across underwriting, policy, billing, and claims. Jaeton brings a strong understanding of the insurance technology landscape and works with carriers to align business goals with scalable, long-term system strategies.
(Featured image credit: ImageFlow/Adobe Stock)
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.