Judge Rules Ohio State Workers' Comp Fund Overcharged Employers; Fund Will Appeal

Ohio employers could share refunds totaling $861 million if a court decision holding that the state workers' compensation fund overcharged employers is upheld.

Judge Richard J. McMonagle of Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court (Cleveland) made such a ruling March 3 and will hold a hearing on the decision March 14.

James DeRoche, a partner at Seaman Garson L.L.C., Cleveland, says McMonagle could finalize the decision that day or shortly afterwards.

The decision was a response to a class-action lawsuit first filed in 2007.

In his decision, McMonagle ruled that the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation knowingly charged inequitable rates to some employers.

“ …the evidence that has been established since the preliminary injunction displays that the BWC was aware of the inequity in the system; was aware it was violating the statutory mandate; and was aware that the non-group employers were charged excessive premiums dating back to 1991,” McMonagle says.

“By charging non-group employers excess premiums that the BWC knowingly created inequity, the BWC engaged in a course of conduct that it knew violated the very purpose of the statute,” the judge adds.

 “We definitely intend to appeal,” says Bill Teets, BWC communications director. “As far as the group-rating program, it rewards small companies for getting together and maintaining safer workplaces.” 

Teets contends, “The decision is based on the concept that BWC fund was enriched by the way the group rating program at the time was set up. We disagree. We don’t believe the plaintiffs suffered any harm that entitled them to restitution.”

More than 270,000 of the 300,000 employers in the class defined by the court would get refunds if the decision is sustained, DeRoche and Teets agreed.

DeRoche said that a BWC appeal just to the next highest state-appellate court would delay the refunds for a year; an appeal to the state’s highest court would mean the refunds would be delayed up to two years.

“It depends on what the state wants to do,” DeRoche says. “Whether the BWC wants to be stubborn, or whether it wants to pay the people the money back that they are owed promptly,” he said.

DeRoche cites a PowerPoint presentation to the court indicating that the “BWC has a surplus of over $7.9 billion even after taking a contingent liability charge of $854 million due to our lawsuit.”

He says the surplus substantially exceeds the BWC’s own guidelines.

But Teets disagrees. He says the BWC maintains its surplus in order to stabilize rates in the face of high-claims years, potential high medical costs and the fact that WC claims have a long tail.

Teets notes that the BWC is currently dealing with some claims dating back to the 1940s.

DeRoche says that some claimants will get perhaps $250, but others up to $50,000, and others up to $1 million. The largest payment will be $1.6 million.

He says 77,000 employers will get more than $1,000, and 50,891 employers stand to get over $2,000.

Teets defended the state. He said that during the period covered by the lawsuit, from July 2001 to June 2009, claims costs for the plaintiffs in the class exceed premiums paid by $861 billion, and the BWC’s net assets declined by $2.5 billion.

But DeRoche said that argument “completely missed the point; they are talking at cross-purposes.”

DeRoche says the BWC argument “is completely irrelevant to the issue as to whether they overcharged some employers for the coverage during the period. 


Resource Center

View All »

Contractors General Liability Coverage 102

What is a prior work exclusion? Which option is right for my client? Why do...

Sign up today to get a 50% matching credit -...

Insurance marketing sometimes seems like it's a game of swings and misses, but we're here...

Guide: 5 Steps to Selling Cyber

Cyber risk and data security is on the agenda of every business owner and executive....

Citation Correlation

Do rigger and signalperson qualifications correlate with the cause of crane and rigging accidents? ...

Complete Guide to Electronic Signatures in Property & Casualty Insurance...

In property and casualty insurance, closing new business quickly is key. Learn how to leverage...

INSTANT ACCESS: Complimentary Sales Closer Questionnaires

Help property owners or managers compare your commercial residential property insurance coverage vs. the competition....

Determining Vacant Property Perils and Valuations

Are your clients fully covered for Vacant Properties? In this economic climate, your insureds may...

Risk Management for Law Firms

This package of 3 concise risk management articles offers straightforward content and practical suggestions law...

Guide: Top 15 E&O Risks-And How To Avoid Them

Accidents happen. But when it's an errors and omissions oversight, that accident can open your...

We'll Show You How to Reach Your Sales Goals

Whether you work alone or have a team of agents working for you, we can...

PropertyCasualty360 Daily eNews

Get P&C insurance news to stay ahead of the competition in one concise format - FREE. Sign Up Now!

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.