Historic Villanova Mansion Charred in Suspected Arson

From the Ashes Comes A Lawsuit Against Tenants

The April 4, 2012 blaze in question drew 100 firefighters and took an obvious toll on the Bloomfield mansion. (Photo credit: Dannon Voight ©) The April 4, 2012 blaze in question drew 100 firefighters and took an obvious toll on the Bloomfield mansion. (Photo credit: Dannon Voight ©)

A burning home is a sad sight, made all the more devastating when a piece of history is destroyed with it. In one Pennsylvania town, locals are mourning the battered façade of a once regal country estate after a massive blaze may have ruined it forever.

From the ashes of a powerful fire for which the cause has yet to be determined arises a lawsuit pinning owner against tenant. Among other allegations, the lawsuit cites insurance fraud, wire fraud, arson, and a staged theft. The 53-page court document filed by Jerald Batoff, the owner of the charred mansion, reads more like a screenplay than a lawsuit, complete with an interesting cast of characters, including a mysterious so-called socialite from Montreal and her interior designer/business mogul boyfriend.

A Fairytale Ends

On April 4, 2012, 100 firefighters responded to a blaze at “Bloomfield,” Batoff’s 24,000-square-foot property situated on seven acres just a mere mile away from Villanova University. The Horace Trumbauer-designed mansion features 19 bedrooms, 15 baths and formal gardens, which were designed by the Olmstead Brothers, and is said to epitomize the French Chateau style of architecture reminiscent of the Gilded Age.

Various stakeholders painstakingly restored the mansion to its original beauty, outfitting the property with the conveniences of modernity. What would prompt anyone to deliberately tarnish the history property? Greed, at least by Batoff's estimation.

That legal document Batoff filed on Nov. 29 has raised more than a few eyebrows in Radnor Township, Penn., where Bloomfield is located. In it, Batoff alleges the Canadian couple Dean Topolinski and Julie Charbonneau, who had been occupying the property, hatched a plot to collect millions in insurance money. He asserts the duo duped him, saying they never had any intention to purchase the estate listed for $5.2 million. Instead, Topolinski and Charbonneau strung him along with a $260,000 down payment, monthly lease checks, and other cash siphoned from a company on the verge of collapse, Batoff says. 

After numerous setbacks with a previously agreed upon settlement, the couple requested a long-term lease with an “intent to buy." The charges only get more inflammatory, as Batoff accuses the former tenants of engaging in a “pattern of racketeering activity” dating back to well over a year before the fire. Other allegations include wire fraud, insurance fraud, and a fake break-in at Topolinski’s company, DGI Services, to collect insurance money. (The lawsuit asserts the break-in occurred on Nov. 13, a day before a scheduled lease signing.) 

When the lease was signed, it ostensibly gave the tenants a purported insurable interest under the option to purchase. There is currently no word from the insurer as to whether an investigation is underway; however, the civil suit alleges the couple dismissed groundskeepers and disabled the home’s security system before the fire to “cover their tracks.”

The fire marshal ruled the cause “undetermined,” and in May 2012, the renters filed an insurance claim and received $1.25 million in an advance payoff. The case took another turn in late October, as U.S. District Judge William H. Yohn Jr. issued a temporary restraining order freezing insurance proceeds Batoff had collected for the fire. While nothing is as it seems in this shady scenario, the adage “buyer beware” could certainly apply to the seller in this case. Only time will tell. 



Resource Center

View All »

Increase Sales Conversion with this Complimentary White Paper

This whitepaper will share proven techniques - used by many of the industry's top producers...

D&O Policy Definitions: Don't Overlook These Critical Terms

Unlike other forms of insurance where standard policy language prevails, with D&O policies, even seemingly...

Environmental Risk: Lessons Learned from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate...

Whether it’s a chocolate factory or an industrial wastewater treatment facility, cleanup and impacts to...

More Data, Earlier: The Value of Incorporating Data and Analytics...

Incorporating more data earlier in claims lifecycles can help you reduce severity payments by 25%*...

How Many Of Your Clients Are At Risk Of Flood?

Every home is vulnerable to flooding. Learn four compelling reasons why discussing flood insurance with...

Gauging your Business Intelligence Analytics Capabilities and the Impact of...

Big Data, Data Lakes and Data Swamps, How to gauge your company's Big Data readiness....

Extending Contact Center Capabilities Across the Insurance Enterprise

Today advancements in technology are making a big impact on business and society. To yield...

Drug and Alcohol Testing Requirements

In this two-part series, NBIS Risk Management team will break down the requirements to assist...

Why Cyber Liability is Essential for Human Service Organizations

For traditional low-tech operations, information is often compromised in ways that don't involve technology. Access...

A Solution for Large Commercial Habitational Accounts

6 Reasons to place your LARGE Habitational Accounts with Dauntless.

Forensic Insider eNewsletter

Get investigative information and forensic insight to help you reach optimal claims outcomes – FREE. Sign Up Now!

Claims-Handling Guidelines

Claims Magazine is providing the following free guidelines and regulations in order to help adjusting professionals stay abreast of each state’s unique property and casualty claim-handling requirements.

View our State Guidelines »

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.