Filed Under:Markets, Personal Lines

Higher Rates, Lack of Coverage Likely After States' Hurricane Deductible Decision: Industry Rep

Credit: NOAA
Credit: NOAA

Insurance companies are smarting over the decision by six states and the District of Columbia to tell insurers they cannot impose hurricane deductibles for losses suffered from “Superstorm” Sandy.

Neil Alldredge, senior vice president, state & policy affairs, for the National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies, says the ultimate impact from the decision will likely be higher insurance rates for everyone.

Moreover, Alldredge says, it will result in another rethinking by companies as to how much coastal risk they can afford to underwrite.

Rhode Island was the latest state to notify insurers they could not invoke the hurricane deductible in settling personal-lines claims stemming from the storm.

Besides D.C. and Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania and Maryland have made similar statements to insurers.

Alldredge says the states acted based on a decision by the National Weather Services just before Sandy’s landfall to change its designation from a hurricane to an “extra-tropical cyclone.”

But he contends that the NWS acted despite the fact that Sandy had all the characteristics of a hurricane, which would have triggered the deductible.

“These deductibles are important risk-management tools,” Alldredge says. “An insurer makes decisions on the coastal property they will underwrite based on these practices. This changes the economic impact on insurers.

He adds, “We recognize that there is a human element to all of this. We acknowledge that it will change the out-of-pocket costs for a person with a loss,” but he explains that “insurance companies need to rely on the certainty of the policy language and to after-the-fact determine that that language is not enforceable alters the economic decision-making that a company can make.”

He the risk-profile now changes substantively, and that impacts the costs that an insurer anticipates it will absorb if an event takes place.

“That is the situation we are dealing with now,” Alldredge says. “If we are going to have this type of revolving door of decisions, then why have the hurricane deductible at all?” he asks.

He notes that the issue first arose last year, when Hurricane Irene came ashore. “This is what spawned the controversy, in most cases, in the same states,” he says.

The difference was that Irene was a hurricane and the NWS did not change the designation before it hit land.

Alldredge says many insurance companies were asked not to enforce the hurricane deductibles and some complied and others didn’t.

But with Irene, Alldredge says, “It was a hurricane. In this case [Sandy], you have this phantom decision just before landfall that all of a sudden this was not a hurricane, even though it walked like a duck and quacked like a duck.”

Top Story

Ferguson burning: 9 scenes of property damage in the wake of the riots

A grand jury in Ferguson, Missouri on Monday declined to indict a local police officer in the August 2014 shooting death of 18-year-old Michael Brown, setting off a night of violent riots in the suburban St. Louis community. Here's the aftermath.

CE & Training

One Low Price for Complete Access to All Courses

Choose from National Underwriter's complete library of courses available in your state to get the credits you need quickly and affordably. Take advantage of the Open Pass Package for only $49. Click here to start your training today!

More Resources

Comments

eNewsletter Sign Up

Personal Lines Pro eNewsletter

Critical insights into the personal auto, homeowners, and other consumer insurance markets to help P&C professionals stay informed – FREE! Sign Up Now!

Mobile Phone
         

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.