Filed Under:Agent Broker, Commercial Business

Modern-Day Heists: Top 10 Collectibles at Risk

Non-cash Items are attractive, valuable targets for burglars

By Laura Bergan, vice president of sales and marketing of American Collectors Insurance

If you believe Hollywood’s depiction of a typical heist, you’d think that only cars and cash are the targets for thieves looking to strike it rich. Not so. The files of the Federal Bureau of Investigation are filled with cases of stolen art collections, militaria, and even moon rocks.


Antiques collections are the most-targeted item for thieves because they’re hard to trace and easy to resell. And thieves go to great lengths. Just ask a Norwell, Mass. couple whose antique weathervane valued at more than $10,000 was stolen from on top of their home, leaving a cheap tin replica in its place.

Baseball, Football and Sports Cards

Baseball and football card collections are similarly targeted. Only very rare cards collected by active collectors (those who attend shows or are communicating regularly with other card collectors) would be difficult to unload without attracting attention.

Coin Collections

As one of the most sought-after items for thieves, coin collections are easy to steal and seemingly easy to dispose of. Even so, some thieves have no idea how valuable some of the coins can be. A collector in Oregon was reunited with most of his coin collection after thieves deposited them in a supermarket coin counting machine. They got $450. The collection was worth several thousand dollars.

Crystal & Glass

Depression glass, crystal goblets, even stained glass items are targets for thieves. One of the more notorious thefts of crystal involved the crystal ball, now housed in Philadelphia’s Penn Museum, which is rumored to have been lifted from Empress Cixi of the Qing dynasty (1835-1908). 

Die-Cast Models

Model cars are a big collector market, and thieves aren’t sparing the Hot Wheels. Considering that a model of Boba Fett's starship Slave I from Star Wars sold on eBay for an impressive $779 US dollars, it’s an attraction for thieves, petty or otherwise.

Dolls, Stuffed Animals and Doll Houses

Keep your Barbies under close surveillance: These dolls are sought-after targets for burglars. One collection of 25 dolls valued at $2,000 was stolen in Virginia last year. That estimate pales in comparison to one collector’s Barbie stash – 5,000 total – that was valued at $1 million at the time it was stolen in 1992. Though uninsured, the collection was recovered later that same year.

Entertainment, Media, Movie and Record Collections

Who knew that poster of Flubber would be so valuable? When a California man pleaded not guilty in March 2012 to stealing movie posters and reselling them, the victim (CBS) valued the posters at $450,000.


Your aunt’s figurines aren’t just pretty – they’re valuable. A St. Louis woman was sentenced to 12 months in jail for stealing Steuben Crystal glass figurines at more than $15,000 from a local residence.

Guns and Fishing Gear

Thieves target guns. In one case, a firearms dealer returning home after a gun show had more than $200,000 in guns stolen from his truck as he sat inside a restaurant.

Military Gear and Historic Collections

Any item of historic significance can be stolen. Take the case of the Civil War flag from the Indiana War Memorial Museum that was swiped in 1997. It took 10 years, but the flag was finally returned when an antiquities dealer spotted the flag while visiting a business liquidation sale and notified the FBI. The flag, valued at $50,000, is now back with the museum.

Featured Video

Most Recent Videos

Video Library ››

Top Story

Baby, it’s cold outside! Here are 6 tips for staying safe in sub-zero temperatures

Extreme temperatures bring risks to people and property. Make sure you are taking care of yourself and your surroundings.

Top Story

5 ways insurance agencies can improve their websites

The way people use the Internet has changed over the past few years. Has your website changed with it?

More Resources


eNewsletter Sign Up

Agent & Broker Insider eNewsletter

Proven success tips and essential information to help agents and brokers grow their practice – FREE. Sign Up Now!

Mobile Phone

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.