Filed Under:Agent Broker, Agency Management

Balance Sales and Retention

Real success involves being both a hunter and a gatherer

History can be a great teacher. In early times, mankind survived by way of the "hunter/gatherer" mindset. The men would go out in the morning to hunt for food and the women would gather the wild bounty of the earth. However, there would be times when game became scarce or competition increased from nearby tribes. Likewise, the wild bounty was subject to the vicissitudes of Mother Nature. Obviously, there needed to be another way to provide the necessary sustenance for survival.

Thus, mankind involved into a balance between "hunter/gatherer" and "rancher/farmer." People could both grow crops and enjoy the natural bounty, while the bounty of the hunt could be augmented by raising cattle.

Related: Read Jack Burke's previous column, "Producers: Plan or Perish."

In many ways, that same balance continues today and serves as an appropriate analogy for insurance sales. The successful agency must develop effective methods to hunt and bring home new business, while properly nurturing existing clients for loyalty and retention. Success is the result of a balance between the two, as opposed to exclusive focus on either single category.

It seems like a simple formula, and it is. But implementation is not necessarily easy.

Generally, articles about sales concentrate on gaining new business, but today I’d like to address the retention side of selling. When writing my book, "Relationship Aspect Marketing," I opened with some statistics that have weathered the test of time in relation to why businesses lose their customers.

Those numbers listed in the chart show that more than two-thirds of the customers who leave you will do so because they feel that you don’t care—that you simply take them for granted. Our inattention results in a withering relationship that just goes away to a more ardent suitor. These clients didn’t just arbitrarily leave; we drove them away by not giving them their due.

Relationships are like a skittish horse. They need attention on a regular basis. Hold back on the attention for too long and the horse becomes anxious and unruly. However, you also must set boundaries on relationships. If not, the expectations can get out of hand and destroy the relationship as well.

There’s an old Sanskrit proverb that deals with the timeline of yesterday, today and tomorrow. It was written in the fifth century by Kalidasa, an Indian poet:

Look to this day, for it is life, the very life of life.
In its brief course lie all the realities and verities of existence,
The bliss of growth, the splendor of action, the glory of power—
For yesterday is but a dream, and tomorrow is only a vision.
But today, well lived, makes every yesterday a dream of happiness
And every tomorrow a vision of hope.
Look well, therefore, to this day.

If we were to paraphrase that to business, it might go, "Yesterday’s efforts will not insure tomorrow’s clients; it is what you do today that counts."

So what do you need to do today to solidify and enhance your relationships with existing clients?

Multiplicity versus singularity

In the past, client relationships tended to be singular in nature. The owner or CEO was the primary decision-maker, simply requiring the producer to maintain that relationship. Golf games and dinners were the primary methods in this relational buddy system. Today, that has totally changed. Senior management may still be involved in the form of a COO or CFO, but insurance decisions are more frequently left to mid-level risk managers, committees or even outside consultants. Today, most accounts require maintenance touches at multiple levels, and these various critical contacts often have differing perspectives, needs and concerns.

That being the case, today’s successful producer must keep a finger on numerous pulses and be prepared to bring a variety of resources to the table to meet these differing needs on a professional level.

Today’s relationships need constant vigilance as well. As the saying goes, the only constant is change, and the speed of change is escalating on an exponential basis in this challenging economy.

For instance, a large business here in Branson, Mo., recently partnered with a similar organization in California to provide additional economic strength for both parties. As always, a merger of this sort resulted in a realignment of operations to maximize the value of each other’s core competencies. That realignment resulted in moving the insurance decisions to a risk management department within the California operations. Although managing officials in Branson might sign the renewal contracts, they are merely implementing instructions arriving from California.

In this very common situation, insurance relationships can be in serious jeopardy—particularly if the respective producers are caught off guard. Long relationships with the California risk management team are suddenly faced with new competition from the local Missouri provider. Likewise, the local Missouri provider is at risk from the old relationships that exist in California. Vigilant monitoring of a client’s plans and activities can provide an early warning signal that enables the producers to begin creating and developing the newly required relationships. Lack of vigilance, on the other hand, can quickly lose the account to the new competition without a fight.

Just as business continues to bring more individuals into the process, some successful agencies are doing the same. Rather than relying on a singular relationship of producer to client, these agencies are utilizing a team approach to the relationship management of accounts. Assuming the team is effectively sharing information, such interaction at multiple levels can result in stronger relationships and a deeper understanding of your client’s needs and concerns. This enables the insurance agency to become more proactive in partnering for problem resolution and success strategies for their clients. Remember, as a professional, you are much more than an insurance "peddler." You are a true partner with your client.

Manage expectations

This topic could justify a book in itself. Unfortunately, most expectations are set by producers who tend toward exuberant promises in landing the account—and these are usually one-way guidelines:

"If this happens, we’ll do this…"

Proper management of expectations involves actions by both parties.

"If you implement a wellness program, we can begin working toward stabilization of health insurance premiums…"
"If you enhance your safety program, we can work together in reducing your experience mod…"

A simplified example that took place when we moved here involved our trash collector. He knocked on the door, introduced himself and said, "I’d like to be your trash collector. If you will bag it up in large plastic trash bags, then I will pick it up once a week for $10."

He set the expectations and the boundaries. He explained what I had to do and what he would do, as well as setting a price. In doing so, he also positioned himself to "wow" us with services over and above what he had promised. That is the way a professional producer will establish relational boundaries, manage expectations and cultivate the potential to deliver beyond a client’s expectations.

As we move further into 2011, today might be a good time to take a moment and really assess how well you nurture your client relationships. I’ve often said that if we put 50 percent of the energy we expend to develop new clients into nurturing our existing ones, we would have the best of both worlds: high rates of new client acquisition, coupled with excellent client retention. We have the technology for frequency in touching the client, but nothing is more powerful than the personal touch that acknowledges the unique needs and concerns of an individual client. It lets them know that you truly value their business.

Take a lesson from ancient mankind. Drive your prospects from the bushes, but never forget to nurture the cattle that will sustain you in tough times. By keeping your activities in balance and harmony, you can have the best of both worlds.

Featured Video

Most Recent Videos

Video Library ››

Top Story

The trouble with estimating additional living expenses (ALE)

ALE provides coverage for additional living expenses over and above the insured's normal living expenses.

Top Story

Identity theft takes the sparkle off of the holiday shopping season says new study

Cyber risks affect shopping patterns, according to Generali Global Assistance.

More Resources


eNewsletter Sign Up

Agent & Broker Insider eNewsletter

Proven success tips and essential information to help agents and brokers grow their practice – FREE. Sign Up Now!

Mobile Phone

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.