Broker Rolls Back Workers' Comp Advice for Relief Veterinarians

Critics say many relief veterinarians are independent contractors, not employees.

They aren’t saying they goofed, but the insurance broker for the American Veterinary Medical Association’s Professional Liability Insurance Trust (AVMA PLIT) plans to “clarify” advice that came out in 2009, stating that relief veterinarians needed workers' compensation insurance even though most are independent contractors.

Relief veterinarians are hired to work weekends, holidays and other periods when a member of a veterinary practice or animal hospital cannot be present. The statement by the PLIT's longtime broker Hub International Midwest, Ltd., that relief veterinarians should be covered by workers' compensation insurance created confusion among practitioners. Critics of the advice argued that it ran contrary to the distinction and tax status of many relief veterinarians as independent contractors, in addition to forcing the practice owners hiring them to pay increased insurance premiums.

Mike Ahlert, executive vice president of Hub International, said the clarification will be issued in the next AVMA Business Insurance Update, a quarterly advice column that goes out to PLIT policyholders. The article, slated for release in April, will feature counsel originally drafted for the San Diego County Veterinary Medical Association (SDCVMA), authored by William K. Browning, an employment lawyer at Klinedinst PC in San Diego.

"Workers' comp is only for employees, not independent contractors retained by an employer,” Browning said in an interview.

Browning's article for the SDCVMA reviewed tests that veterinary practices and relief veterinarians can use to determine independent contractor status, which can be complicated and yield legal problems and even fines if determined incorrectly. For example, veterinarians who are independent contractors retain the right to determine on their own the means and methods used to treat patients. If they are employees, the practice owner has the right to specify how the job is performed.

States Set the Guidelines

Ahlert said the 2009 article in the AVMA Business Insurance Update titled “Questions and Answers — Relief Veterinarians,” was intended to bring clarity to the independent contractor issue but ended up muddying the question all the more. He said there is no “black and white answer” to independent contractor status question; each state has its own guidelines.

Hub International is not the only broker of workers' compensation insurance for the veterinary profession but is a major player. Ahlert estimated that about a quarter of veterinary practices in the United States buy their workers' compensation coverage through PLIT-sponsored programs. The Hartford is the major underwriter for workers' compensation insurance offered through PLIT-sponsored programs, he said. (To further illustrate the relationship, Hub International acts as a store front selling The Hartford policies. The PLIT sponsors the broker's insurance programs for AVMA members.)

David Smith, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry, said Pennsylvania does not have specific independent contractor guidelines for relief veterinarians and that there is no general “litmus test” to make that determination. He pointed to Internal Revenue Service Publication 1779, “Independent Contractor or Employee?” for federal guidance on the definition of an employee. Smith noted that relief veterinarians do not qualify for workers' compensation insurance if they're determined to be independent contractors.

The uproar concerning the 2009 article largely was limited to Southern California, home to many relief veterinarians, Ahlert said. Pauline White, executive director of the San Diego County Veterinary Medical Association (SDCVMA), said a member contacted her to complain after the article appeared. White’s initial attempts to clarify the matter with HUB International yielded hazy answers.

Claims and Counter Claims

The issue quieted but resurfaced when a second SDCVMA member expressed concern, reporting that she was being required to obtain workers' compensation insurance by the practice where she was working as a relief veterinarian. Complaints also came from Dr. Elizabeth Kelly, who stated that The Hartford was overcharging her as a practice owner—a claim that Ahlert flatly denies. Last fall, the carrier tried to force Kelly, owner of Jamacha Veterinary Clinic in El Cajon, Calif., to pay workers' compensation insurance for the relief practitioners she has hired since 2009, if she could not prove that they purchased personal coverage.

Another issue, and one that plagues many policyholders: Kelly was being charged to insure herself, even though California law allows practice owners to opt out of covering themselves with workers' compensation insurance. In an email to the VIN News Service, Ahlert insisted that The Hartford and Hub International follow state labor laws. "As I explained to Dr. Kelly, this subject is open to interpretation ... The fact that Dr. Kelly does not agree with Hartford does not mean they are cheating her," he stated.

Nevertheless, such situations have been fodder for message board discussions on the Veterinary Information Network (VIN), an online community for the profession where Kelly is a member.

"If I cave and agree to pay for my relief vet's workers' compensation, then it opens me up to an IRS audit because they would be classified as employees and I would owe back taxes," she stated in an email to the VIN News Service in December. In a later interview, she said: "They wanted certificates of insurance for anyone who worked on the premises making more than $600 in my clinic. That includes the guy who tunes up our anesthesia machine and the person who sharpens our clipper blades."

Kelly added that her premiums for workers' compensation insurance are calculated at 3.8 percent of payroll. She spends $60,000 to $100,000 a year on relief veterinarians and mobile surgeons, and when she failed to fill out the audit form required by The Hartford and sent to her via Hub International, the underwriter automatically upped her premiums by 15 percent.

Talking It Out

In response the troubles reported by Kelly and others, the SDCVMA's White arranged a meeting between Dr. Deborah Harvazinski, the secretary-treasurer of the SDCVMA who also is a relief veterinarian, and Dr. Rodney G. Johnson, CEO of the AVMA PLIT. Harvazinski provided the perspective of a relief veterinarian affected by information in the article, White said. Bottom line: Assessments of an individual's employment status are conducted by relevant tax and labor authorities—not insurance underwriters or agencies.

Just before Christmas, the company changed its stance. Ahlert assured Kelly that The Hartford and Hub International would no longer charge her in reference to the independent contractors she hires to work in her practice and issued her a refund on the premium she'd been paying to insure herself. Around the same time, the PLIT's Johnson assured the SDCVMA that the issue surrounding independent contractors would be clarified.

“We are very involved in looking after the interests of our members. We look forward to AVMA clarifying that article," White said.

This article originally was distributed by the VIN News Service and is reprinted with permission. Author David DeKok is a freelance journalist based in Harrisburg, Penn. Journalist Jennifer Fiala contributed to the article.

Page 1 of 2
Comments

Resource Center

View All »

Complimentary White Paper: The Compression of Workplace Time

How brokers and carriers respond to the compression of workplace time will create significant competitive...

The Changing Insurance Consumer: 6 Ways to Create Profitable Relationships

Today’s mobile and web-savvy consumers have new expectations when it comes to interacting with your...

Contractors General Liability Coverage 102

What is a prior work exclusion? Which option is right for my client? Why do...

Sign up today to get a 50% matching credit -...

Insurance marketing sometimes seems like it's a game of swings and misses, but we're here...

Guide: 5 Steps to Selling Cyber

Cyber risk and data security is on the agenda of every business owner and executive....

Citation Correlation

Do rigger and signalperson qualifications correlate with the cause of crane and rigging accidents? ...

Complete Guide to Electronic Signatures in Property & Casualty Insurance...

In property and casualty insurance, closing new business quickly is key. Learn how to leverage...

INSTANT ACCESS: Complimentary Sales Closer Questionnaires

Help property owners or managers compare your commercial residential property insurance coverage vs. the competition....

Determining Vacant Property Perils and Valuations

Are your clients fully covered for Vacant Properties? In this economic climate, your insureds may...

Risk Management for Law Firms

This package of 3 concise risk management articles offers straightforward content and practical suggestions law...

Looking for Markets?

Search Kirschner’s Insurance Directory to help service your hard to place risks.

497 Risk Categories | 70,000 P&C Insurance Markets

kirschners
Specialty Markets Insight eNewsletter

Receive updates and analyses on hard to place and challenging coverages. Sign Up Now!

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.