Judge Denies Insurer's Attempt To Stop Policy Coverage For Drywall

NU Online News Service, Dec. 3, 1:33 p.m. EST

National Union Fire Insurance Company of Pittsburgh, a Chartis company, was not successful in getting a federal judge in Florida to say the insurer has no duty to defend or indemnify a drywall contractor.

The contractor, F. Vicino Drywall Inc., is named as a defendant in 17 lawsuits related to allegedly defective Chinese drywall and recently filed a motion to dismiss a motion by National Union for summary judgment on the basis that policy exclusions clear the company from having to defend or indemnify National Union.

National Union issued three umbrella policies to F. Vicino. The insurer was seeking a ruling that it owes nothing to F. Vicino, though the Deerfield Beach, Fla.-based contractor has not yet requested payment or reimbursement of defense costs from National Union, according to a ruling from U.S. District Court in the Southern District of Florida.

F. Vicino filed a motion to dismiss based on the fact there is no controversy.

"I conclude that this action does not qualify as a proper case or controversy," wrote Judge Alan S. Gold. "Even if all the allegations in the complaint are true, [National Union] has not alleged a judgment or settlement that would exhaust the primary insurance and trigger its own excess policies.

"The parties' liabilities at this time are merely contingent and may never materialize," the judge continued.

Judge Gold said National Union may file an amended complaint if a controversy--that its policies will indeed be called upon by F. Vicino--arises.

Amerisure Cleared of Coverage

In other drywall-related litigation out of the Southern District of Florida, a judge ruled Amerisure Mutual Insurance Co. will not have to defend a builder against drywall-related lawsuits because policies between the two were written after damages in an underlying case occurred.

Amerisure sought a summary judgment against Albanese Popkin the Oaks Development Group, which is being sued by a homeowner alleging damage due to the alleged corrosive effects of Chinese drywall.

Amerisure issued a commercial general liability policy to Albanese in January 2008. The suit against Albanese relates to alleged damaged first reported by the homeowners in 2006 but Albanese, and the homeowners, argue that the damage was continuous.

"The fact that the damage was continuous in nature is irrelevant to the court's analysis," wrote Judge Kenneth A. Marra in granting Amerisure's motion. "Therefore, there is no coverage or duty to defend."

Comments

Resource Center

View All »

Top 10 Legal Requirements for E-Signatures in Insurance

Want to make sure you’ve covered all your bases when adopting e-signatures? Learn how to...

Get $100 in leads with $0 down!

NetQuote's detailed, real-time leads have boosted sales for thousands of successful local agents across the...

The Growing Role of Excess & Surplus Lines in Today’s...

The excess and surplus market (E&S) provides coverage when standard insurance carriers cannot or will...

Increase Sales Conversion with this Complimentary White Paper

This whitepaper will share proven techniques - used by many of the industry's top producers...

D&O Policy Definitions: Don't Overlook These Critical Terms

Unlike other forms of insurance where standard policy language prevails, with D&O policies, even seemingly...

Environmental Risk: Lessons Learned from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate...

Whether it’s a chocolate factory or an industrial wastewater treatment facility, cleanup and impacts to...

More Data, Earlier: The Value of Incorporating Data and Analytics...

Incorporating more data earlier in claims lifecycles can help you reduce severity payments by 25%*...

How Many Of Your Clients Are At Risk Of Flood?

Every home is vulnerable to flooding. Learn four compelling reasons why discussing flood insurance with...

Gauging your Business Intelligence Analytics Capabilities and the Impact of...

Big Data, Data Lakes and Data Swamps, How to gauge your company's Big Data readiness....

Extending Contact Center Capabilities Across the Insurance Enterprise

Today advancements in technology are making a big impact on business and society. To yield...

PropertyCasualty360 Daily eNews

Get P&C insurance news to stay ahead of the competition in one concise format - FREE. Sign Up Now!

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.