(Bloomberg) — Uber Technologies Inc. lost a bid to dismiss a lawsuit over its claims to being safer than taxis.
U.S. District Judge Jon Tigar in San Francisco ruled Friday that the app-based ride-hailing service has made itself out to be "objectively and measurably safer" than competitors.
Yellow Cab Co. and 18 other taxi services that operate in California metropolitan areas including San Francisco and Los Angeles sued Uber in March, alleging it misleads customers about its background checks for drivers and driver safety.
While allowing the case to move forward under a federal false advertising law, Tigar tossed the taxi companies' unfair competition allegations and their demand for restitution under state law.
The judge cited the company's slogan, "Going the distance to put people first," as an example of the company's argument that its advertising claims were nothing more than "puffery."
'Reasonable consumer'
Tigar said other statements could lead "a reasonable consumer" to "conclude that an Uber ride is objectively and measurably safer than a ride provided by a taxi or other competitor service."
Kristin Carvell, a spokeswoman for Uber, didn't immediately respond after regular business hours to an e-mail seeking comment on the ruling.
Founded five years ago in San Francisco with venture capital funding, Uber has grown to serve 300 cities worldwide, stirring conflict with traditional taxi and car-for-hire businesses in Chicago, New York, Paris and Johannesburg. It has said its market value is $50 billion.
Uber was sued in December by the district attorneys of San Francisco and Los Angeles, who accused it of falsely assuring customers that it used "industry-leading standards" to vet its drivers while failing to use fingerprints to check criminal histories.
The case is L.A. Taxi Cooperative Inc. v. Uber Technologies Inc., 15-cv-01257, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California (San Francisco).
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.