Subprime E&O Exposure Varies By State
By Susanne Sclafane
Illinois, Michigan and Massachusetts are among 11 states with very high risks of professional liability lawsuits arising out of the subprime mortgage crisis, according to a new report.
The December report–"What's the State of Your State? E&O Risk Uneven Across The Country," published by Guy Carpenter, a New York-based reinsurance broker–provides a state-by-state overview of the threat of errors and omissions litigation on U.S. real estate professionals.
According to Guy Carpenter, high foreclosure rates alone won't put a state in the high-risk category for E&O lawsuits. For example, Arizona and Nevada have two of the highest foreclosure rates in the country–2.0 percent and 4.2 percent, respectively–but "low" and "medium" risks to E&O lawsuits.
The lawsuit risk is based on the "Guy Carpenter Subprime E&O Litigation Index," a measure developed by the firm to take a combination of factors into account that influence the E&O litigation climate for each state (see accompanying infographic).
Guy Carpenter has found that the riskiest states in terms of potential litigation are those that have average rankings in most of these categories and an extremely high result in a single category. Just having one high score–just a high foreclosure rate or just a high subprime delinquency rate, for example–won't push the overall index into the "high-risk category."
For example, an exhibit in the report shows that Maine has a high subprime mortgage delinquency rate–14.6 percent, compared to 14.5 percent for the United States overall. With almost no history of banking litigation, however, Maine is "low risk" in terms of E&O lawsuit potential.
On the other hand, Massachusetts, which is roughly average or just slightly above average for most factors captured by the index, is at "very high risk" for E&O lawsuits because the combination of slightly high factors produces an extremely high risk outcome.
Based on the index, the other states with very high E&O lawsuit risk are: Connecticut, Rhode Island, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Tennessee, Georgia, Alabama and Louisiana.
"It is important to underscore that E&O litigation related to the subprime mortgage crisis could impact any state, even those not classified by our index as particularly risky," said Kevin Griffiths, head of Guy Carpenter's Global Casualty Specialty Practices, in a statement.
"As the subprime mortgage crisis…unfold[s] and the litigation landscape continues to evolve, the states claiming the highest risk levels in our index are likely to change as well," he added.
In an earlier report published in November–"Credit Market Aftershock Threatens Professional Liability Profits"–Guy Carpenter noted that total E&O insurance losses could climb as high as $16 billion just for mortgage brokers. Deriving the figure, the report noted that there are 53,000 licensed mortgage brokers, and in accordance with regulation, they must carry limits of $300,000 in E&O insurance.
Assessing E&O potential for professionals other than mortgage brokers, Guy Carpenter also listed rating agencies among the most worrisome "high exposure" E&O classes, while assessing regional banks, home appraisers, real estate agents, bond insurers, hedge and private equity funds in the "medium exposure" category.
Experts are also keeping tabs on securities fraud class-action filings that may be covered under directors and officers insurance policies as precipitous drops in the share values of publicly traded subprime mortgage lenders, homebuilders and guaranty insurers spawn such litigation. On the D&O side, Guy Carpenter has said insured losses could approach $3 billion.
More recently, Advisen, a New York-based provider of technology and data to the commercial insurance industry, put a $3.6 billion estimate on potential D&O losses, and analysts at Bear Stearns in New York developed a worst-case estimate of $8-$9 billion.
Infographic:
Flag: Checklist
Head: How Is The Index Determined?
The factors used to calculate the "Guy Carpenter Subprime E&O Litigation Index" are:
o The percentage of mortgages in foreclosure.
o The percentage of subprime mortgages that are delinquent.
o The number of litigation attorneys per mortgage industry professional.
o The frequency of truth-in-lending lawsuits (per million households) through the third quarter of 2006.
o The frequency of banking-related lawsuits (per million households) through the third quarter of 2006.
o The extent to which a state is plaintiff-friendly–measured by its ranks among "Judicial Hellholes" identified by the American Tort Reform Association.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.