Attorneys for a Houston engineering firm and State Farm Insurance said they would not appeal a Mississippi judge's ruling denying most of their requests to restrict a criminal probe into the handling of Hurricane Katrina insurance claims.
Circuit Judge Stephen B. Simpson in Gulfport, Miss., issued his ruling April 4 after Rimkus Consulting Group and State Farm brought actions seeking to limit a grand jury investigation mounted by Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood.
Mr. Hood and Harrison County District Attorney Cono Caranna are examining allegations that engineering reports may have been altered to minimize wind damage.
Dave Ward, an attorney for Rimkus in Houston, told National Underwriter, “We don't believe at this point we will further seek to limit the subpoena by the attorney general or Judge Simpson's order.
He said the firm intends to speak with representatives of the attorney general's office about the information they are seeking and how best to comply.
Mr. Ward added, “There is a potentially large amount of documentation.”
The subpoena, according to the judge's order, originally sought confidential documents related to insurance carriers or other entities that are “neither targets nor subjects of a grand jury investigation.”
It sought all engineering reports prepared for all insurance companies as a result of Hurricane Katrina in Hancock, Harrison and Jackson Counties.
Judge Simpson found the request was too broad-based and ordered that the attorney general limit the request to specific insurers and adjusters.
He gave Rimkus 30 days to produce the engineering reports once the attorney general's office names the companies it wants.
The judge also ordered that procedures to maintain confidentiality that he established for production of State Farm documents be used for the Rimkus reports.
In Jackson, Miss., Robert C. Galloway of the Butler, Snow, O'Mara Stevens & Cannada law firm representing State Farm, said there were no further legal proceedings scheduled on the matter for State Farm.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.