Class-Action Flood Suit Filed Over Definition of ‘Basement’

A Jersey City, N.J. man has filed a federal class-action, breach-of-contract lawsuit against a group of nine insurers he says is denying claims based on their flawed definition of a “basement.”

 The named insurance-company defendants—all issuers of flood policies under the “Write Your Own” (WYO) program with the Federal Emergency Management  Agency (FEMA)—are New Jersey Manufacturers (NJM), State Farm, The Hartford, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Selective, Assurant, Fidelity National and Philadelphia Contributorship.

Patrick Donnelly’s specific claim stems from 2011, when he had a flood policy issued under the WYO program by NJM’s New Jersey Re-Insurance Co.

After Hurricane Irene, Donnelly filed a flood claim but was sent a denial letter from FEMA last February based on what the suit calls an “erroneous classification of the lowest floor of [Donnelly’s] building as a ‘basement.’” 

The lawsuit claims this alleged wrongful denial has occurred numerous times to home and business owners after Irene and Superstorm Sandy. 

The lawsuit does not detail the area of Donnelly’s home that was allegedly mischaracterized by an adjuster. 

NJM responded to the suit by saying it has no incentive to act in bad faith during the claims-adjusting process because, as a WYO carrier, it receives a fee for every dollar paid to a homeowner under a flood policy.

Featured Video

Most Recent Videos

Video Library ››

Top Story

The state of New Orleans: 10 years after Hurricane Katrina

Watch as NU-PC360 tours the still abandoned homes and lots of the Lower Ninth Ward, the new construction booming in the up-and-coming Lakeview and the new levee floodgates on the Violet Canal.

Top Story

6 lessons insurers learned from Katrina

Ten years later, Katrina is still making an impression. Numerous lessons were learned from Katrina that have helped insurers and other first responders better prepare for other catastrophes. Some may seem obvious, but others demonstrate just how much has changed in the past decade.

More Resources

Comments

eNewsletter Sign Up

PropertyCasualty360 Daily eNews

Get P&C insurance news to stay ahead of the competition in one concise format - FREE. Sign Up Now!

Mobile Phone

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.