Greenberg Fires Comeback to U.S. Motion to Dismiss $25B Lawsuit

Maurice Maurice "Hank" Greenberg, former chairman of insurer AIG. (AP Photo/Stephen Chernin, file)

NU Online News Service, March 30, 11:26 a.m. EST

Former American International Group Inc. chief executive Maurice “Hank” Greenberg isn’t giving up on his $25 billion lawsuit against the U.S. over its bailout.

In a March 28 filing by Starr International Co., which Greenberg is chairman of, the company argues that it has a right to seek compensation for itself and AIG shareholders because the government illegally took AIG property through massive wealth transfers and mismanaged the 2008 bailout of AIG while preventing its collapse.

Late last year, Starr filed a lawsuit in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims against the government, claiming it violated the Constitution when it took majority ownership of AIG without compensating the company’s shareholders.

The government followed by filing a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, saying AIG asked and agreed to be rescued, and that Starr has no authority to sue.

Greenberg’s Starr says the government’s actions in AIG’s case “stood in stark contrast to the government’s far more favorable treatment of similarly situated entities [during the financial crisis].”

“Other companies received guarantees or loans at far more favorable interest rates, either of which would have addressed AIG’s liquidity problems without the massive wealth transfers mandated by the government,” says Starr, AIG’s largest shareholder before the bailout.

At one time the government held a 77 percent stake in AIG. It now holds about a 70 percent stake after AIG’s latest payback. However, Starr says the government violated the Fifth Amendment by taking private property for public use without just compensation.

Furthermore, the government cannot claim AIG consented to the deal when it denied shareholders the right to withhold consent—a circumvention of shareholders’ voting rights under state law, alleges Starr.

Starr adds that the government pressured AIG’s board to accept an inferior offer and misled the board to thinking it was the only offer.

“The government offered terms that were objectively grossly overreaching and much more extreme than alternatives that the government could have rationally accepted and would have accepted,” Starr proclaims in its court filing. “This strategy forced the AIG board into an unnecessary game of ‘chicken’ with the global economy, leaving the board with no choice but to yield.” 

Comments

Resource Library

View All »

Bring the Benefits of Decision Tree Analysis to Your Everyday...

In this on-demand webinar, learn how to counter the challenges of litigation with predictive analytics...

Learn and Apply the Secrets of Successful Businesses to Your...

What does it take to elevate your agency to be known as the best of...

Have you outgrown your QA system?

Your claims audit tools must handle organizational growth and changing best practices. Download the "25...

Complimentary Sales Closer Questionnaires for Commercial Residential Property Insurance

Help property owners or managers compare your commercial residential property insurance coverage vs. the competition....

The Latest Business Intelligence Capabilities to Reduce Costs and Enhance...

SIMS Insight is the advanced business intelligence module of SIMS Claims. Want more information? Download...

Top Trends in Roof Risk Mitigation

Get an in-depth look at the progression of the roof problem, including a four-step path...

When Banks Won't Help, Oak Street Funding Will.

Our commission-based loans are designed to help agents and brokers invest in their business, consolidate...

Home Run Leads are Here!

Our high quality leads will have you swinging for the fences and knocking your sales...

We Have Your New Formula for Success!

Your goal is to deliver maximum impact on those critical aspects of business that drive...

Complimentary White Paper: What Makes a House a Home?

The restoration vendor is the first person on site after a disaster strikes a home...

Producer Profiles: Share Your Stories

PropertyCasualty360 invites all brokers and agents to showcase their businesses and themselves with our readers. Tell us why you became an agent, what makes you successful and who you look up to--and we'll feature your achievements here on PC360 and highlight some of the profiles in the pages of Property Casualty 360 – National Underwriter and American Agent & Broker.

Agent & Broker Insider eNewsletter

Proven success tips and essential information to help agents and brokers grow their practice – FREE. Sign Up Now!

Advertisement. Closing in 15 seconds.